Two Voices of Queen
One band, two singers. Freddie Mercury's story ended in 1991; Adam Lambert's story is still going on. Two tenses tell the difference: the past simple for what is finished, the present perfect for what is still true today.
Warm-up
Watch the start of each video. They have no captions: just watch and listen. Then ask and answer with a partner, or with me. Tap a card when you have answered it.
One song, two voices. The first video is from 1985. That singer's story is finished, so we tell it in the past simple. The second singer's story is still going on, so his story needs the present perfect too.
Useful language
Music words
Click a word, then click its meaning. Correct pairs turn green. The audio button says the word.
Complete the sentences
Click a word in the bank, then click a gap. Click a filled gap to clear it. Read the whole sentence first: the clue is always inside it.
She has a beautiful voice, so she is the
_____ in our group.
He can't sing and he doesn't play an instrument, but other musicians love his words and music. He is a great
_____.
The
_____ broke a string in the middle of the song, so the music stopped.
At the end of the concert, the
_____ threw his sticks to the fans.
Our
_____ has four people: two play guitar, one plays bass and one plays the drums.
Her new
_____ has twelve songs, and I downloaded it yesterday.
The musicians will play in ten cities in three weeks: the
_____ starts in Rio.
She won an
_____ for the best song of the year, and she cried on stage.
Past simple or present perfect?
Read the four boxes with me. Then the practice starts in Exercise 05.
Finished, or still true? That is the only question. A finished time — yesterday, in 1991, two years ago — takes the past simple. No time, or a time that is still open — ever, for ten years, since 2009 — takes the present perfect.
- Affirmative: I studied music. · She wrote a song. · They played in London. Regular verbs take -ed; irregular verbs change: write → wrote, go → went, be → was / were.
- Negative: didn't + verb. He didn't study music. · We didn't play last night.
- Question and short answer: Did + person + verb. Did you study music? — Yes, I did. / No, I didn't.
- Time words: yesterday, last night, last week, in 1991, ten years ago, from 1998 to 2000.
- Affirmative: I have played in a band. · He has played in a band. · It has been in a band. Short forms: I've, he's, they've.
- Negative: haven't / hasn't + participle. I haven't played in a band. · She hasn't played in a band.
- Question and short answer: Have you played in a band? — Yes, I have. / No, I haven't. · Has he played in a band? — Yes, he has. / No, he hasn't.
- Time words: ever, never, just, already, yet, once, twice, many times, for, since.
- For + a period: He has worked with the band for ten years. · Since + the start: Since 2009, he has sold three million albums. · The question: How long has he worked with the band?
- — Have you heard the new album yet? (present perfect: no time)
- — Yes, I have. I listened to it at Tony's house yesterday. (past simple: the details)
- — Did you like it? — I loved it!
- Careful with for: it also works with the past simple, but only for a period that is finished. They were together for two years. (They aren't together now.) · They have been together for two years. (They are still together.)
Finished, or still true?
Read the sentence and choose the tense and the reason. Look for the time words: a finished time, a time that is still open, or no time at all? Click an answer and read why.
-
"I've lived here for ten years."
For ten years, and I still live here. The period started in the past and is open today.
-
"We didn't have Mark's party last weekend."
Last weekend is over. Didn't + verb is the past simple negative.
-
"She's been to London twice."
An experience: two visits in her life, and no date. She's here means she has.
-
"Samantha was married to Paul for five years."
Was married for five years: the marriage is finished. For a marriage that is still going on, we say she has been married for five years.
-
"They've lived in France since 2011."
Since 2011 gives the start, and they are still in France today.
-
"She hasn't bought any food for lunch."
The recent past with no time: the result is now — there is no food for lunch. Hasn't bought is the present perfect.
-
"His family lived in Denmark from 1998 to 2000."
From 1998 to 2000: a period with a start and an end. It is finished.
-
"Brian's worked here since 2015."
Brian's = Brian has. He started in 2015, and he still works here.
-
Which sentence is correct?
Since needs the present perfect: I've had. The present simple with since is a very common mistake for Portuguese speakers.
-
Which sentence is WRONG?
Last year is finished, so it needs the past simple. This year is still open, so the present perfect is fine there.
Past simple or present perfect + verb
Write the verb on the left in the past simple or the present perfect. Short forms are fine: I've worked. Read the whole sentence first: the time words tell you which tense.
-
workI ___ in this office since 2018.
-
takeYesterday he arrived home, ___ a shower and went to bed early.
-
just / loseA: What's wrong? B: I ___ my glasses!
-
meetMy parents ___ each other when they were in college.
-
liveI ___ in this city for three years. I love it here.
-
you / goWhat time ___ to work yesterday morning?
-
you / ever / see___ that movie?
-
breakLucy ___ her leg, so she can't play with us.
-
you / knowHow long ___ Jill?
-
breakJack ___ his arm when he fell off a horse in 2005.
-
Which sentence is correct?
In 1978 is a finished time, so only the past simple works: was.
-
Which sentence is WRONG?
Since takes the start (since 2021); for takes the period (for four years). Since four years mixes the two.
Choose the right form
One form is correct in each sentence. Is the time finished, or is it still open? Click an answer and read why.
-
She ___ in Berlin since May.
Since May gives the start, and she is still in Berlin: present perfect. Is … since is the classic mistake.
-
Adrian ___ school two years ago.
Two years ago is a finished time. Ago always goes with the past simple.
-
I ___ in São Paulo for two years, but then I moved to Rio.
For two years, but the period is finished: then I moved to Rio. For with the past simple.
-
Joana ___ at this company since March.
Since March and still here: present perfect. The participle of be is been, never being.
-
My sister ___ her baby two years ago.
Two years ago: finished time, past simple. Had is the past of have.
-
The school ___ a lot since we started studying here.
Since we started: from that moment until now. The changes are still true today.
-
Sofia and James are divorced now. They ___ married for ten years.
They are divorced, so the marriage is finished: were married for ten years. Have been married would mean they are still married.
-
I ___ my husband when I was on vacation in the USA.
When I was on vacation is a finished moment in the past, so the first verb is past simple too.
-
Which sentence is correct?
He still lives there (he loves it), so for a year takes the present perfect. For … ago does not exist.
-
Which sentence is WRONG?
In 2019 is a finished time and cannot go with the present perfect. The second sentence is fine: a finished period with for.
A conversation about a concert
The conversation starts in the present perfect and changes to the past simple for the details. Click a word in the bank, then click a gap. Each word is used once.
- A: _____ you ever been to a big concert?
- B: Yes, I _____.
- B: I _____ Queen + Adam Lambert in Rio a few years ago.
- A: Wow! And _____ you like it?
- B: I loved it! We _____ in the first row, very close to the stage.
- A: Who _____ with you?
- B: My brother. He _____ a Queen fan since he was a teenager.
- A: Lucky you! I _____ seen them live yet.
-
— Have you ever seen Queen live? Which reply is correct?
The short answer copies the question: Have you…? — Yes, I have. Then the detail, in 2015, goes to the past simple.
-
Which sentence is WRONG?
Last year is a finished time, so it needs I went. I've never been is fine: it is about your whole life, with no time.
Make the interview questions
Write the full question with the words on the left. How long asks about a period that is still open; when, how and why ask for a detail in the past. You use these questions in Exercise 12.
-
aHow long / you / live / there?
-
bWhen / you / born?
-
cWhen / you / move / there?
-
dHow long / you / work / there?
-
eWhen / you / start?
-
fHow long / you / know / him?
-
gHow / you / meet?
-
hHow long / you / study / English?
-
iHow long / you / have / it?
-
jWhy / you / buy / it?
-
Your partner still has the same best friend. Which question is correct?
The friendship started in the past and is still true, so how long takes the present perfect. Did you know would mean the friendship is over.
-
Which question is WRONG?
When asks for a finished moment, so it goes with the past simple: When did you move? How long have you lived is fine: the period is open.
Two voices, one band
Two short biographies: one story is finished, one is still going on. The verbs are in bold: which ones are past simple, and which ones are present perfect? Tap a dotted word to see what it means.
Freddie Mercury was born on September 5, 1946, in Zanzibar, an island in Africa. In 1964, his family left Zanzibar and moved to England.
In London, Freddie studied art and played music with friends. Then he formed a band with the guitarist Brian May and the drummer Roger Taylor: Queen.
Freddie wrote many of the band's hits, like "Bohemian Rhapsody" and "We Are the Champions", and Queen became famous all over the world.
In 1985, Queen played at Live Aid, a big charity concert in London. About 72,000 people were there, and millions more watched it on TV.
In 1990, Freddie and the band received the Brit Award for Outstanding Contribution to British Music. A year later, in 1991, Freddie died of complications from AIDS, at the age of 45.
The band lost its voice, but the music didn't stop. Many years later, a new voice appeared on a TV show in the United States.



That voice was Adam Lambert's. He is an American singer, songwriter and actor, born in 1982. In 2009, he became famous on the TV show American Idol.
That year, Brian May and Roger Taylor came to the show, and Adam sang "We Are the Champions" with them. It was his first time with Queen.
After the show, Adam started his solo career. Since then, he has released several albums and has sold more than three million. The first, "For Your Entertainment", was number three in the U.S.
In 2012, Adam and Queen went on their first tour. He has now collaborated with the band for more than ten years, and their album "Live Around the World" was number one in the UK in 2020.
Multiple choice
Click an answer and read why. Two questions are about the tenses in the story.
-
What did Freddie's family do in 1964?
Freddie was born in Zanzibar, an island in Africa, in 1946. In 1964, his family left Zanzibar and moved to England. That is why the rest of his story happens in London.
-
Who formed Queen with Freddie?
Brian May played the guitar and Roger Taylor played the drums. Freddie was the singer.
-
What did Freddie write for Queen?
Many hits, like "Bohemian Rhapsody" and "We Are the Champions". A hit is a very popular song.
-
What was Live Aid?
A concert for charity in 1985: about 72,000 people in the stadium and millions more at home, in front of the TV. The first video in the warm-up is from that show.
-
What happened one year after the Brit Award?
The award was in 1990, and Freddie died in 1991, at the age of 45. Live Aid was earlier, in 1985.
-
Which tense tells Freddie's story, and why?
Freddie is not alive anymore, so every event in his life happened in a finished time: was born, formed, wrote, died.
-
How did Adam Lambert become famous?
The eighth season of American Idol, in 2009. In 1985, at the time of Live Aid, Adam was only three years old.
-
When did Adam sing with Queen for the first time?
Brian May and Roger Taylor came to the show, and Adam sang "We Are the Champions" with them. The first tour came three years later.
-
What has Adam done since 2009?
Three million albums since 2009, and the number is still growing. That is why the story says has sold, not sold.
-
How long has Adam collaborated with Queen?
Their first tour together was in 2012, more than ten years ago. In 1991, when Freddie died, Adam was only nine years old.
-
Adam's story says has released, has sold and has collaborated. Why the present perfect?
His career is still going on, so these numbers can still grow. But his finished moments take the past simple, like Freddie's: was born in 1982, became famous in 2009.
-
Which sentence best summarizes the story?
Freddie's story ended in 1991, so we tell it in the past simple. Adam's story continues today, so his biography uses the present perfect for what is still true. The two singers come from different countries, and Queen did not stop.
How long…? When…?
Part A is the interview: ask a partner (or me) the questions from Exercise 09 and ask for more details. Then retell your partner's answers to the class. Part B is about your life. Part C is for your opinions.
Useful language
A short biography
40–70 words. Choose a famous person you admire. If the person is not alive, write the story in the past simple. If the person is alive, use the past simple for the finished moments (was born, became famous in …) and the present perfect for what is still true (has sold, has lived in … since …).
My results
Check your score, then copy it and send it to your teacher on WhatsApp.
One job for this week. Every day, say two true sentences about you: one that is finished (I lived in … until 2019) and one that is still true (I've lived in … since 2019). Finished: past simple. Still true: present perfect.